Tschermakite
A strongly aluminous calcic amphibole species, idealised Ca₂(Mg₃Al₂)(Si₆Al₂)O₂₂(OH)₂. A useful substitution end member, but not confirmed as a Lizard occurrence here.
Language and route: Historical linguistic transmission: Commemorative surname; Mineralogical suffix. Surname of mineralogist Gustav Tschermak + -ite; the root is an eponym and should not be forced into Greek.
Literal gloss: Surname of mineralogist Gustav Tschermak + -ite; the root is an eponym and should not be forced into Greek.
Original-language roots
- Tschermak — Commemorative surname: Gustav Tschermak von Seysenegg
- -ite — Mineralogical suffix: named mineral
Mineral family and Cornish petrology
Mineral family: Amphibole supergroup · species
Silicate structural class: Inosilicates — chains. Classification is distinct from mineral species and Cornish occurrence.
- Composition
- A strongly aluminous calcic amphibole species, idealised Ca₂(Mg₃Al₂)(Si₆Al₂)O₂₂(OH)₂.
- Mineral classification
- IMA-grandfathered mineral species
- Cornish petrography
- An end-member for evaluating Al-rich amphiboles in Lizard metagabbros and amphibolites; the cited Cornwall studies do not individually establish tschermakite.
- Petrogenesis
- The coupled tschermakite substitution Alᴵⱽ+Alⱽᴵ ↔ Siᴵⱽ+Mgⱽᴵ is an important chemical control on amphibole composition and metamorphic evolution.
- Hand specimen
- Commonly dark amphibole; cannot be separated from other species visually.
- Plane polarised light
- Amphibole cleavage and pleochroism, not a test of Tschermak substitution.
- Crossed polars
- Oblique extinction and variable colours; species identification requires chemistry and structural constraints.
- Interpretation limits
- A theoretical substitution component in a chemical model does not certify a natural mineral occurrence or local phase identity.
Cornish rock-assemblage links
- Lizard hornblende schists and metamorphic sole · evidence class V · comparative Al-rich amphibole end-member
E = named in regional literature, S = supported association, V = verification required. A regional link is not a certified specimen identification.
The name and its history
Winchell (1945 conceptual precursor); IMA amphibole specialists · Winchell 1945 hypothetical end-member; modern species definition later; first exact name appearance unresolved.
- What does the word literally mean?
- Surname of mineralogist Gustav Tschermak + -ite; the root is an eponym and should not be forced into Greek.
- What did the original author mean?
- Winchell’s 1945 formulation of a hypothetical “Tschermak molecule” is a chemical-structural antecedent; it is not automatically the first naming-page for the now-defined tschermakite species.
- Why was the name needed?
- Could the aluminium-for-silicon and aluminium-for-magnesium substitution in calcic amphiboles be expressed as a stoichiometric end-member?
- What evidence supported the original concept?
- A 1945 end-member discussion and the 2012 amphibole report track successive forms of a composition that is now defined by explicit site occupancy. An epithet honouring Tschermak does not imply that he personally described the modern species.
- How has geology changed the concept?
- In metabasites, identify tschermakite from analyses rather than treating aluminous amphibole indiscriminately as hornblende. The chemical substitution mechanism is distinct from its naming history.
Further historical context
*Original-language etymology.* Surname of mineralogist Gustav Tschermak + -ite; the root is an eponym and should not be forced into Greek. Winchell’s 1945 formulation of a hypothetical “Tschermak molecule” is a chemical-structural antecedent; it is not automatically the first naming-page for the now-defined tschermakite species.
*Chronology.* Winchell 1945 hypothetical end-member; modern species definition later; first exact name appearance unresolved. Contributors: Winchell (1945 conceptual precursor); IMA amphibole specialists.
*Scientific question and evidence.* Could the aluminium-for-silicon and aluminium-for-magnesium substitution in calcic amphiboles be expressed as a stoichiometric end-member? A 1945 end-member discussion and the 2012 amphibole report track successive forms of a composition that is now defined by explicit site occupancy. An epithet honouring Tschermak does not imply that he personally described the modern species.
*Modern mineralogical/petrological interpretation.* In metabasites, identify tschermakite from analyses rather than treating aluminous amphibole indiscriminately as hornblende. The chemical substitution mechanism is distinct from its naming history.
*Unresolved first-publication task.* Verify Winchell 1945 primary printed page, determine first use of the exact mineral species name, and differentiate model molecule from a natural species.
Editorial qualification
Verify Winchell 1945 primary printed page, determine first use of the exact mineral species name, and differentiate model molecule from a natural species.
Related names
Sources
- L. J. Spencer (1946), Seventeenth list of new mineral names, Mineralogical Magazine 27 (citing Winchell 1945) — Historical bibliographic notice for Winchell’s 1945 hypothetical Tschermak molecule; no original 1945 page reviewed
- Handbook of Mineralogy, Tschermakite (mineral data publisher) — Composition and species placement, commemorative naming; page not independently facsimile checked
- Hawthorne et al. (2012), Nomenclature of the amphibole supergroup, American Mineralogist 97:2031–2048 — Species/group nomenclature, site occupancy and compositional roots
- Leake et al. (1997), Nomenclature of amphiboles, European Journal of Mineralogy 9:623–651 — History of successive classification schemes and abandonment of imprecise old names