Pigotite
A historically named, poorly characterised aluminium-bearing organic substance or mineral-like crust.
Language and route: Scientific European mineralogical naming; see history. J. F. W. Johnston described the substance in 1840 and associated the name with the Rev. M. Pigot, who helped obtain the material.
Literal gloss: honouring the Rev. M. Pigot
Original-language roots
- Pigotite — Modern mineralogical naming; original languages in historical account: honouring the Rev. M. Pigot
The name and its history
J · An Al bearing organic compound. J.F.W.Johnston (1840) Phil.Mag. 3rd. ser., 17, Hey 3.
- What does the word literally mean?
- The naming etymology is honouring the Rev. M. Pigot. J. F. W. Johnston described the substance in 1840 and associated the name with the Rev. M. Pigot, who helped obtain the material.
- What did the original author mean?
- J. F. W. Johnston described the substance in 1840 and associated the name with the Rev. M. Pigot, who helped obtain the material.
- Why was the name needed?
- The unusual brown encrustations presented a classificatory question: should a substance formed through the decay of wet vegetation on granite count as a new mineral?
- What evidence supported the original concept?
- The 1840 description and subsequent Cornish accounts placed it on weathered granite in a biologically influenced environment; composition and homogeneity were not established to modern standards.
- How has geology changed the concept?
- Modern mineral registers mark pigotite questionable, despite its inherited/grandfathered historical listing. It must be presented as a disputed historical species, not a straightforward modern approved Cornwall mineral.
Further historical context
J. F. W. Johnston described the substance in 1840 and associated the name with the Rev. M. Pigot, who helped obtain the material.
The unusual brown encrustations presented a classificatory question: should a substance formed through the decay of wet vegetation on granite count as a new mineral?
The 1840 description and subsequent Cornish accounts placed it on weathered granite in a biologically influenced environment; composition and homogeneity were not established to modern standards.
Modern mineral registers mark pigotite questionable, despite its inherited/grandfathered historical listing. It must be presented as a disputed historical species, not a straightforward modern approved Cornwall mineral.
Editorial qualification
questionable historical species; not asserted as a valid modern distinct mineral; Cornish historical locality at Cripp’s Cove, Treen; modern TL status uncertain
Related names
Sources
- Golley & Williams (1995), Cornish Mineral Reference Manual, PDF p. 72
- www.mindat.org — Pigotite historical/modern evidence — Mineralogical nomenclature, historical description or original paper (verification varies by source)