Neotocite
Amorphous or poorly crystalline hydrated manganese–iron silicate, approximately (Mn,Fe)SiO₃·H₂O.
Language and route: Distinguish etymology, original referent, and later modern taxonomy. Nordenskiöld’s neotocite name, introduced in 1848 and published in 1849, uses Greek for newly produced or of recent origin to refer to a secondary alteration product. John Henry Collins used a geographically Cornish name, penwithite, in 1878 for apparently new silicate material.
Literal gloss: Greek “newly produced”; Penwith place-name for the superseded Cornish term
Original-language roots
- Neotocite — Historical borrowing detailed in five-question narrative: Greek “newly produced”; Penwith place-name for the superseded Cornish term
The name and its history
Nordenskiöld’s neotocite name, introduced in 1848 and published in 1849, uses Greek for newly produced or of recent origin to refer to a secondary alteration product · J.H.Collins (1878) Mineral.Mag. 2, 91. and(1879)3,89.
- What does the word literally mean?
- Greek “newly produced”; Penwith place-name for the superseded Cornish term. Nordenskiöld’s neotocite name, introduced in 1848 and published in 1849, uses Greek for newly produced or of recent origin to refer to a secondary alteration product. John Henry Collins used a geographically Cornish name, penwithite, in 1878 for apparently new silicate material.
- What did the original author mean?
- Neotocite was described from the Erik Ers Mine, Torsåker, Sweden. Collins’s Penwith specimen from Wheal Owles was resinous, hydrated, reddish brown and unusual, but it was not the earlier Swedish type material.
- Why was the name needed?
- What makes an amorphous alteration product a mineral species if X-ray diffraction yields no coherent structure? Initial observations relied on colour, conchoidal fracture, water loss and chemical response rather than crystal symmetry.
- What evidence supported the original concept?
- Golley and Williams (1995, PDF p. 66) cite Collins’s 1878 and 1879 papers under neotocite, identifying Wheal Owles (penwithite) and Geevor. Clark, Easton and Mount (1978) investigated metatype specimens of Swedish neotocite and Cornish penwithite, showing why the older name should be used.
- How has geology changed the concept?
- Neotocite is still listed as a valid grandfathered but amorphous mineral. Penwithite is treated as a historical synonym; the physical similarity of other amorphous Mn-silicates means identification confidence should not be inflated.
Further historical context
Nordenskiöld’s neotocite name, introduced in 1848 and published in 1849, uses Greek for newly produced or of recent origin to refer to a secondary alteration product. John Henry Collins used a geographically Cornish name, penwithite, in 1878 for apparently new silicate material.
Neotocite was described from the Erik Ers Mine, Torsåker, Sweden. Collins’s Penwith specimen from Wheal Owles was resinous, hydrated, reddish brown and unusual, but it was not the earlier Swedish type material.
What makes an amorphous alteration product a mineral species if X-ray diffraction yields no coherent structure? Initial observations relied on colour, conchoidal fracture, water loss and chemical response rather than crystal symmetry.
Golley and Williams (1995, PDF p. 66) cite Collins’s 1878 and 1879 papers under neotocite, identifying Wheal Owles (penwithite) and Geevor. Clark, Easton and Mount (1978) investigated metatype specimens of Swedish neotocite and Cornish penwithite, showing why the older name should be used.
Neotocite is still listed as a valid grandfathered but amorphous mineral. Penwithite is treated as a historical synonym; the physical similarity of other amorphous Mn-silicates means identification confidence should not be inflated.
Editorial qualification
Valid (grandfathered) amorphous mineral; penwithite is historical Cornish synonym, not valid separate species.; original referent: Erik Ers Mine, Torsåker, Sweden; Wheal Owles, Cornwall is the historical penwithite original locality
Related names
Sources
- Golley and Williams (1995), Cornish Mineral Reference Manual, PDF p. 66
- Specialist mineral entry: Neotocite — Nomenclature, naming provenance, current chemistry and modern status
- Additional independent scholarly or specialist source — Independent research pointer; full original text was not necessarily inspected