Natromontebrasite
Discredited historical name for material now shown to consist of OH-rich amblygonite/montebrasite-associated minerals, including lacroixite and wardite.
Language and route: See detailed historical-language account. Waldemar T. Schaller proposed the compound name natromontebrasite in 1911, combining natro- for sodium with the known mineral montebrasite. The name was an explicit chemical comparison, not an independent geographical reference to Cornwall. Modern review by Fransolet, Fontan and de Parseval discredited it in 2007.
Literal gloss: natro- sodium + resemblance to montebrasite
Original-language roots
- Natromontebrasite — Detailed historical linguistic route below: natro- sodium + resemblance to montebrasite
The name and its history
Waldemar T · M.Stone and M.C.George (1983) Proc.Ussher Soc. 5, 428-31.
- What does the word literally mean?
- natro- sodium + resemblance to montebrasite. Waldemar T. Schaller proposed the compound name natromontebrasite in 1911, combining natro- for sodium with the known mineral montebrasite. The name was an explicit chemical comparison, not an independent geographical reference to Cornwall. Modern review by Fransolet, Fontan and de Parseval discredited it in 2007.
- What did the original author mean?
- Waldemar T. Schaller proposed the compound name natromontebrasite in 1911, combining natro- for sodium with the known mineral montebrasite. The name was an explicit chemical comparison, not an independent geographical reference to Cornwall. Modern review by Fransolet, Fontan and de Parseval discredited it in 2007.
- Why was the name needed?
- Bulk chemical analyses of Li–Na–Al phosphate mixtures could suggest a sodium analogue of montebrasite. The central classification question was whether sodium occupied structural sites in a single homogeneous species or came from physically intergrown phases.
- What evidence supported the original concept?
- Golley and Williams (1995, p. 66) cite Stone and George (1983) for a first British occurrence at Tremearne Pegmatite, Breage. That record belongs in a historical occurrence catalogue, but cannot be reused as evidence for a valid modern species.
- How has geology changed the concept?
- Combined crystal chemical and microscopic work reinterpreted the original “natromontebrasite” as OH-rich amblygonite plus lacroixite, with subsidiary wardite. The entry is retained for the history of pegmatite identification and as a searchable discredited name.
Further historical context
Waldemar T. Schaller proposed the compound name natromontebrasite in 1911, combining natro- for sodium with the known mineral montebrasite. The name was an explicit chemical comparison, not an independent geographical reference to Cornwall. Modern review by Fransolet, Fontan and de Parseval discredited it in 2007.
Bulk chemical analyses of Li–Na–Al phosphate mixtures could suggest a sodium analogue of montebrasite. The central classification question was whether sodium occupied structural sites in a single homogeneous species or came from physically intergrown phases.
Golley and Williams (1995, p. 66) cite Stone and George (1983) for a first British occurrence at Tremearne Pegmatite, Breage. That record belongs in a historical occurrence catalogue, but cannot be reused as evidence for a valid modern species.
Combined crystal chemical and microscopic work reinterpreted the original “natromontebrasite” as OH-rich amblygonite plus lacroixite, with subsidiary wardite. The entry is retained for the history of pegmatite identification and as a searchable discredited name.
Editorial qualification
DISCREDITED in 2007 as a mineral mixture; do not list as an accepted currently distinct Cornish species.; original locality: Cañon City area, Colorado, USA (historic original description)
Related names
Sources
- Golley & Williams (1995), Cornish Mineral Reference Manual, PDF p. 66
- Mindat — naming history, status, and type context: Natromontebrasite — Current specialist historical and mineral status reference
- Supporting published history, original study or scientific reference — Supporting published reference. Full original document checked only if explicitly noted.