Mottramite
PbCu(VO₄)(OH), copper–lead vanadate hydroxide.
Language and route: Historical naming and borrowing interpreted with source-appropriate qualifications. Named for Mottram St Andrew in Cheshire, linked with the copper-bearing Triassic sandstone where Roscoe worked; the geographical referent is not a Cornish locality. Evidence suggests some original stockpiled material may have come from Pim Hill, Shropshire.
Literal gloss: Named for Mottram St Andrew in Cheshire, linked with the copper-bearing Triassic sandstone where Roscoe worked; the geographical referent is not a Cornish locality. Evidence suggests some original stockpiled material may have come from Pim Hill, Shropshire.
Original-language roots
- Mottramite — Historical/eponymic or geographical: Named for Mottram St Andrew in Cheshire, linked with the copper-bearing Triassic sandstone where Roscoe worked; the geographical referent is not a Cornish locality. Evidence suggests some original stockpiled material may have come from Pim Hill, Shropshire.
The name and its history
Henry Enfield Roscoe · 1876/1877
- What does the word literally mean?
- Named for Mottram St Andrew in Cheshire, linked with the copper-bearing Triassic sandstone where Roscoe worked; the geographical referent is not a Cornish locality. Evidence suggests some original stockpiled material may have come from Pim Hill, Shropshire.
- What did the original author mean?
- Roscoe announced a vanadium-bearing lead–copper mineral in 1876 and published it in Proceedings of the Royal Society, volume 25 (1877). The name distinguished a crust-forming vanadate whose mineralogical identity had been approached under several other names.
- Why was the name needed?
- Identifying a vanadium mineral was difficult because mottramite can approach zinc-bearing descloizite or arsenate-bearing duftite in solid solution; even “type” material has uncertain extraction provenance.
- What evidence supported the original concept?
- The 1995 catalogue (p. 65) references G. S. Camm and M. Merry (1991), recording Penberthy Croft Mine (St Hilary) and Dean Quarry (St Keverne). These are not original 1876 Cheshire/Shropshire material. A detailed Russell Society study compared Roscoe-related material with recent Mottram specimens using infrared spectra, X-ray diffraction and analysis.
- How has geology changed the concept?
- PbCu(VO₄)(OH) is now the copper-rich end-member of the descloizite–mottramite series; arsenate substitution connects towards duftite. The historical type-locality question remains more complicated than the straightforward name “Mottram” implies.
Further historical context
Roscoe announced a vanadium-bearing lead–copper mineral in 1876 and published it in Proceedings of the Royal Society, volume 25 (1877). The name distinguished a crust-forming vanadate whose mineralogical identity had been approached under several other names.
Identifying a vanadium mineral was difficult because mottramite can approach zinc-bearing descloizite or arsenate-bearing duftite in solid solution; even “type” material has uncertain extraction provenance.
The 1995 catalogue (p. 65) references G. S. Camm and M. Merry (1991), recording Penberthy Croft Mine (St Hilary) and Dean Quarry (St Keverne). These are not original 1876 Cheshire/Shropshire material. A detailed Russell Society study compared Roscoe-related material with recent Mottram specimens using infrared spectra, X-ray diffraction and analysis.
PbCu(VO₄)(OH) is now the copper-rich end-member of the descloizite–mottramite series; arsenate substitution connects towards duftite. The historical type-locality question remains more complicated than the straightforward name “Mottram” implies.
Editorial qualification
Valid species; type-material provenance disputed, historical Cornish reports recorded for Penberthy Croft and Dean Quarry.
Related names
Sources
- Mottramite — specialist mineralogical register — Current nomenclature, formula, naming and original-bibliography secondary register
- Roscoe (1877), On two new vanadium minerals — Original naming publication bibliographic record, first reported 1876
- Russell Society, Mottramite type-material comparison — Published study of Roscoe material, infrared and XRD comparison and disputed type provenance
- Bannister (1933), mottramite and psittacinite — Historic analytical reconciliation of aliases and cuprodescloizite
- Golley & Williams (1995), p. 65, MOTTRAMITE
- First Cornish source bibliographical lead from 1995 catalogue