Ben Sumpter.GeoGlossary
Research / Geoscience / Language

Mansfieldite

Hydrated aluminium arsenate, AlAsO₄·2H₂O, variscite group.

Language and route: Scientific term from English personal surname; Mineral suffix. George Rogers Mansfield (surname) + mineral suffix -ite → mansfieldite.

Literal gloss: An American geologist’s eponym, not a reference to Mansfield in Nottinghamshire or to a Cornish mine.

Original-language roots

The name and its history

Victor T. Allen and Joseph J. Fahey; honours George Rogers Mansfield · Allen & Fahey, 1945 meeting programme / 1946 American Mineralogist abstract; full mineral description cited 1948. First printed name in the 1945 programme requires inspection.

What does the word literally mean?
An American geologist’s eponym, not a reference to Mansfield in Nottinghamshire or to a Cornish mine. Transmission: George Rogers Mansfield (surname) + mineral suffix -ite → mansfieldite.
What did the original author mean?
Allen and Fahey presented the new hydrous aluminium arsenate at a 1945 mineralogical meeting (subsequently abstracted in 1946); full descriptions are commonly cited to 1948. These are distinct dates, not interchangeable discoveries.
Why was the name needed?
Was the white arsenate at Hobart Butte, Oregon, the aluminium structural analogue of scorodite?
What evidence supported the original concept?
Chemical and physical comparison with Fe-arsenate scorodite identified AlAsO₄·2H₂O in the variscite/scorodite-type group; a contemporary 1946 mineral-name review explicitly cites the 1945 abstract and 1946 printed abstract.
How has geology changed the concept?
Mansfieldite is a valid grandfathered arsenate species; do not use the place-name similarity or mineral colour to establish an occurrence in Cornwall.

Further historical context

*Original language and naming route.* An American geologist’s eponym, not a reference to Mansfield in Nottinghamshire or to a Cornish mine. Allen and Fahey presented the new hydrous aluminium arsenate at a 1945 mineralogical meeting (subsequently abstracted in 1946); full descriptions are commonly cited to 1948. These are distinct dates, not interchangeable discoveries. George Rogers Mansfield (surname) + mineral suffix -ite → mansfieldite.

*Early history.* Allen & Fahey, 1945 meeting programme / 1946 American Mineralogist abstract; full mineral description cited 1948. First printed name in the 1945 programme requires inspection. Attributed to: Victor T. Allen and Joseph J. Fahey; honours George Rogers Mansfield.

*Original question and evidence.* Was the white arsenate at Hobart Butte, Oregon, the aluminium structural analogue of scorodite? Chemical and physical comparison with Fe-arsenate scorodite identified AlAsO₄·2H₂O in the variscite/scorodite-type group; a contemporary 1946 mineral-name review explicitly cites the 1945 abstract and 1946 printed abstract.

*Subsequent reinterpretation.* Mansfieldite is a valid grandfathered arsenate species; do not use the place-name similarity or mineral colour to establish an occurrence in Cornwall. Resolve whether the first printed 1945 meeting programme or 1946 abstract is the nomenclatural priority; 1948 description date cannot erase 1945 attribution.

Editorial qualification

Resolve whether the first printed 1945 meeting programme or 1946 abstract is the nomenclatural priority; 1948 description date cannot erase 1945 attribution.

Related names

Scorodite · Pharmacosiderite

Sources

  1. Golley and Williams (1995), Cornish Mineral Reference Manual, PDF p. 61
  2. Specialist mineral entry: Mansfieldite — Contemporary nomenclature and mineralogical history
  3. Spencer (1946), Seventeenth list of new mineral names — Contemporary bibliographic record of 1945/1946 naming
Open this entry in the interactive glossary ↗