Mansfieldite
Hydrated aluminium arsenate, AlAsO₄·2H₂O, variscite group.
Language and route: Scientific term from English personal surname; Mineral suffix. George Rogers Mansfield (surname) + mineral suffix -ite → mansfieldite.
Literal gloss: An American geologist’s eponym, not a reference to Mansfield in Nottinghamshire or to a Cornish mine.
Original-language roots
- Mansfield (George Rogers Mansfield) — English personal surname: USGS geologist commemorated
- -ite — Mineral suffix: mineral-name ending
The name and its history
Victor T. Allen and Joseph J. Fahey; honours George Rogers Mansfield · Allen & Fahey, 1945 meeting programme / 1946 American Mineralogist abstract; full mineral description cited 1948. First printed name in the 1945 programme requires inspection.
- What does the word literally mean?
- An American geologist’s eponym, not a reference to Mansfield in Nottinghamshire or to a Cornish mine. Transmission: George Rogers Mansfield (surname) + mineral suffix -ite → mansfieldite.
- What did the original author mean?
- Allen and Fahey presented the new hydrous aluminium arsenate at a 1945 mineralogical meeting (subsequently abstracted in 1946); full descriptions are commonly cited to 1948. These are distinct dates, not interchangeable discoveries.
- Why was the name needed?
- Was the white arsenate at Hobart Butte, Oregon, the aluminium structural analogue of scorodite?
- What evidence supported the original concept?
- Chemical and physical comparison with Fe-arsenate scorodite identified AlAsO₄·2H₂O in the variscite/scorodite-type group; a contemporary 1946 mineral-name review explicitly cites the 1945 abstract and 1946 printed abstract.
- How has geology changed the concept?
- Mansfieldite is a valid grandfathered arsenate species; do not use the place-name similarity or mineral colour to establish an occurrence in Cornwall.
Further historical context
*Original language and naming route.* An American geologist’s eponym, not a reference to Mansfield in Nottinghamshire or to a Cornish mine. Allen and Fahey presented the new hydrous aluminium arsenate at a 1945 mineralogical meeting (subsequently abstracted in 1946); full descriptions are commonly cited to 1948. These are distinct dates, not interchangeable discoveries. George Rogers Mansfield (surname) + mineral suffix -ite → mansfieldite.
*Early history.* Allen & Fahey, 1945 meeting programme / 1946 American Mineralogist abstract; full mineral description cited 1948. First printed name in the 1945 programme requires inspection. Attributed to: Victor T. Allen and Joseph J. Fahey; honours George Rogers Mansfield.
*Original question and evidence.* Was the white arsenate at Hobart Butte, Oregon, the aluminium structural analogue of scorodite? Chemical and physical comparison with Fe-arsenate scorodite identified AlAsO₄·2H₂O in the variscite/scorodite-type group; a contemporary 1946 mineral-name review explicitly cites the 1945 abstract and 1946 printed abstract.
*Subsequent reinterpretation.* Mansfieldite is a valid grandfathered arsenate species; do not use the place-name similarity or mineral colour to establish an occurrence in Cornwall. Resolve whether the first printed 1945 meeting programme or 1946 abstract is the nomenclatural priority; 1948 description date cannot erase 1945 attribution.
Editorial qualification
Resolve whether the first printed 1945 meeting programme or 1946 abstract is the nomenclatural priority; 1948 description date cannot erase 1945 attribution.
Related names
Sources
- Golley and Williams (1995), Cornish Mineral Reference Manual, PDF p. 61
- Specialist mineral entry: Mansfieldite — Contemporary nomenclature and mineralogical history
- Spencer (1946), Seventeenth list of new mineral names — Contemporary bibliographic record of 1945/1946 naming