Herderite
Fluorine-dominant calcium beryllium phosphate CaBe(PO₄)F; hydroxylherderite is its OH-dominant analogue.
Language and route: See detailed historical-language account. Wilhelm Haidinger named herderite in 1828 after Siegmund August Wolfgang von Herder, a prominent Freiberg mining official. The first species description came from Ehrenfriedersdorf in Saxony, not from Cornwall.
Literal gloss: honouring Siegmund A. W. von Herder
Original-language roots
- Herderite — Historical source and borrowing route in detailed explanation: honouring Siegmund A. W. von Herder
The name and its history
Wilhelm Haidinger named herderite in 1828 after Siegmund August Wolfgang von Herder, a prominent Freiberg mining official · A.W.G.Kingsbury (1958) Mineral.Mag. 29,815-7.
- What does the word literally mean?
- honouring Siegmund A. W. von Herder. Wilhelm Haidinger named herderite in 1828 after Siegmund August Wolfgang von Herder, a prominent Freiberg mining official. The first species description came from Ehrenfriedersdorf in Saxony, not from Cornwall.
- What did the original author mean?
- Wilhelm Haidinger named herderite in 1828 after Siegmund August Wolfgang von Herder, a prominent Freiberg mining official. The first species description came from Ehrenfriedersdorf in Saxony, not from Cornwall.
- Why was the name needed?
- Pale pegmatite phosphates had to be distinguished from other beryllium-bearing phases. Early crystal measurement and chemical recognition could not always resolve the relative F and OH contents.
- What evidence supported the original concept?
- Golley and Williams cite Kingsbury (1958) for Wheal Cock and Colcerrow Quarry (1995 PDF p. 49). That is a historic occurrence report; the 1995 entry does not provide an F/OH assay establishing which end-member was present.
- How has geology changed the concept?
- Current herderite is F-dominant and hydroxylherderite OH-dominant; modern mineral databases caution that a large proportion of old “herderite” specimens are hydroxylherderite. The Cornish identifications should therefore be treated as historically recorded but analytically reviewable.
Further historical context
Wilhelm Haidinger named herderite in 1828 after Siegmund August Wolfgang von Herder, a prominent Freiberg mining official. The first species description came from Ehrenfriedersdorf in Saxony, not from Cornwall.
Pale pegmatite phosphates had to be distinguished from other beryllium-bearing phases. Early crystal measurement and chemical recognition could not always resolve the relative F and OH contents.
Golley and Williams cite Kingsbury (1958) for Wheal Cock and Colcerrow Quarry (1995 PDF p. 49). That is a historic occurrence report; the 1995 entry does not provide an F/OH assay establishing which end-member was present.
Current herderite is F-dominant and hydroxylherderite OH-dominant; modern mineral databases caution that a large proportion of old “herderite” specimens are hydroxylherderite. The Cornish identifications should therefore be treated as historically recorded but analytically reviewable.
Editorial qualification
Valid current species, but the status of individual historical Cornish specimens is unconfirmed against modern F/OH end-member criteria.; original source locality: Sauberg Mine, Ehrenfriedersdorf, Saxony, Germany
Related names
Euclase · Beryl · Amblygonite
Sources
- Golley & Williams (1995), Cornish Mineral Reference Manual, PDF p. 49
- www.mindat.org — mineral history, classification or original publication — Research source; see dossier for whether original historical publication was directly examined