Crandallite
CaAl₃(PO₄)(PO₃OH)(OH)₆, calcium aluminium phosphate of the plumbogummite group.
Language and route: Historic scientific name; see etymology for original language and borrowing pathway. Named for the American mining engineer Milan Lucian Crandall Jr.
Literal gloss: Named for the American mining engineer Milan Lucian Crandall Jr.
Original-language roots
- Crandallite — Personal name: Named for the American mining engineer Milan Lucian Crandall Jr.
The name and its history
Gerald Francis Loughlin and Waldemar T. Schaller · 1917
- What does the word literally mean?
- Named for the American mining engineer Milan Lucian Crandall Jr.
- What did the original author mean?
- Loughlin and Schaller described a calcium aluminium phosphate and named it after the mining engineer associated with the Utah type locality.
- Why was the name needed?
- The then-used name goyazite was compositionally ambiguous; separating calcium and barium phosphate-bearing phases demanded a revised classification.
- What evidence supported the original concept?
- Schaller’s reinterpretation of goyazite as barium-dominant made room for a calcium species called crandallite; the exact 1917 publication passage is a bibliographic, not transcribed, lead.
- How has geology changed the concept?
- Crandallite remains a distinct Ca–Al phosphate in the alunite supergroup. A 1988 Cornwall seminar reference at Wheal Jane records regional use but no verified type priority.
Further historical context
Loughlin and Schaller described a calcium aluminium phosphate and named it after the mining engineer associated with the Utah type locality.
The then-used name goyazite was compositionally ambiguous; separating calcium and barium phosphate-bearing phases demanded a revised classification.
Schaller’s reinterpretation of goyazite as barium-dominant made room for a calcium species called crandallite; the exact 1917 publication passage is a bibliographic, not transcribed, lead.
Crandallite remains a distinct Ca–Al phosphate in the alunite supergroup. A 1988 Cornwall seminar reference at Wheal Jane records regional use but no verified type priority.
Editorial qualification
Valid species; Cornish Wheal Jane note requires independent analytical review.
Related names
Sources
- Crandallite, Mindat mineral register — Modern mineral status, composition and historic name attribution; specialist secondary evidence
- Golley & Williams (1995), extracted PDF p. 33, Crandallite
- Earliest Cornwall source lead printed in 1995 catalogue