Carminite
Carmine-red lead–iron arsenate hydroxide PbFe³⁺₂(AsO₄)₂(OH)₂.
Language and route: See historically specific borrowing discussion. Sandberger described and named “Carminspath” in German in 1850 for its carmine-red colour; Dana rendered the name as carminite in English in 1854.
Literal gloss: carmine-coloured spar
Original-language roots
- Carminite — Historical name; transmission, word class and priority explained in narrative: carmine-coloured spar
The name and its history
Sandberger described and named “Carminspath” in German in 1850 for its carmine-red colour; Dana rendered the name as carminite in English in 1854 · A. Russell. (1910) Mineral.Mag. 15, 285-7.
- What does the word literally mean?
- carmine-coloured spar. Sandberger described and named “Carminspath” in German in 1850 for its carmine-red colour; Dana rendered the name as carminite in English in 1854.
- What did the original author mean?
- Sandberger described and named “Carminspath” in German in 1850 for its carmine-red colour; Dana rendered the name as carminite in English in 1854.
- Why was the name needed?
- A brilliantly red secondary arsenate had to be differentiated from red lead oxide and other brightly coloured oxidation-zone minerals.
- What evidence supported the original concept?
- Sandberger’s locality was the Louise Mine in Germany. Arthur Russell later documented a rare Cornish occurrence in his 1910 Mineralogical Magazine study cited by Golley and Williams at Hingston Down and associated mines.
- How has geology changed the concept?
- It is now a compositionally and structurally defined lead–iron arsenate and dimorph of mawbyite; colour alone cannot distinguish the underlying structure.
Further historical context
Sandberger described and named “Carminspath” in German in 1850 for its carmine-red colour; Dana rendered the name as carminite in English in 1854.
A brilliantly red secondary arsenate had to be differentiated from red lead oxide and other brightly coloured oxidation-zone minerals.
Sandberger’s locality was the Louise Mine in Germany. Arthur Russell later documented a rare Cornish occurrence in his 1910 Mineralogical Magazine study cited by Golley and Williams at Hingston Down and associated mines.
It is now a compositionally and structurally defined lead–iron arsenate and dimorph of mawbyite; colour alone cannot distinguish the underlying structure.
Editorial qualification
Accepted species; documented German original and later Cornish study.; original type context: Louise Mine, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany
Related names
Sources
- Golley & Williams (1995), Cornish Mineral Reference Manual, PDF p. 24
- www.cambridge.org — independent mineralogical history, nomenclature, or original-publication retrospective — Secondary or specialist nomenclature source; first historical paper not personally consulted unless stated