Bustamite
Calcium–manganese pyroxenoid silicate, ideal CaMnSi₂O₆.
Language and route: Original naming event, original specimen and subsequent taxonomic revision distinguished. Alexandre Brongniart introduced bustamite in 1826 for the Mexican mineralogist. Remarkably, subsequent investigation showed the original so-called bustamite to be a mixture rather than the modern species; Larsen and Shannon re-used the name in 1922 for a different but related silicate.
Literal gloss: Honours Mexican naturalist and mineralogist José María Bustamante y Septiem.
Original-language roots
- Bustamite — Naming history described below: Honours Mexican naturalist and mineralogist José María Bustamante y Septiem.
The name and its history
Alexandre Brongniart introduced bustamite in 1826 for the Mexican mineralogist · A.Russell (1946) Mineral.Mag. 27, 221-35.
- What does the word literally mean?
- Honours Mexican naturalist and mineralogist José María Bustamante y Septiem.. Alexandre Brongniart introduced bustamite in 1826 for the Mexican mineralogist. Remarkably, subsequent investigation showed the original so-called bustamite to be a mixture rather than the modern species; Larsen and Shannon re-used the name in 1922 for a different but related silicate.
- What did the original author mean?
- Original nineteenth-century material from the Mexican Real de Minas/Fetela region consisted of a rhodonite–johannsenite mixture; the contemporary species concept therefore cannot simply be projected backwards to Brongniart’s first specimens.
- Why was the name needed?
- The scientific problem is mineral intergrowth: a pink Mn–Ca silicate assemblage can resemble one species when it contains two. Diffraction and composition established the later valid bustamite identity.
- What evidence supported the original concept?
- Golley and Williams (1995, PDF p. 22) cite Russell (1946), Mineralogical Magazine 27, pp. 221–235, and mark Treburland Manganese Mine, Altarnun as a first British occurrence.
- How has geology changed the concept?
- Modern bustamite is a wollastonite-group pyroxenoid with CaMnSi₂O₆ end-member chemistry; the nineteenth-century name was explicitly re-applied in 1922. The original mineral and modern namesake are not identical referents.
Further historical context
Alexandre Brongniart introduced bustamite in 1826 for the Mexican mineralogist. Remarkably, subsequent investigation showed the original so-called bustamite to be a mixture rather than the modern species; Larsen and Shannon re-used the name in 1922 for a different but related silicate.
Original nineteenth-century material from the Mexican Real de Minas/Fetela region consisted of a rhodonite–johannsenite mixture; the contemporary species concept therefore cannot simply be projected backwards to Brongniart’s first specimens.
The scientific problem is mineral intergrowth: a pink Mn–Ca silicate assemblage can resemble one species when it contains two. Diffraction and composition established the later valid bustamite identity.
Golley and Williams (1995, PDF p. 22) cite Russell (1946), Mineralogical Magazine 27, pp. 221–235, and mark Treburland Manganese Mine, Altarnun as a first British occurrence.
Modern bustamite is a wollastonite-group pyroxenoid with CaMnSi₂O₆ end-member chemistry; the nineteenth-century name was explicitly re-applied in 1922. The original mineral and modern namesake are not identical referents.
Editorial qualification
CRITICAL: original “bustamite” was an intergrowth, name re-used.
Related names
Sources
- Golley and Williams (1995), Cornish Mineral Reference Manual, PDF p. 22
- Mineralogical history and classification: Bustamite — Specialist modern naming and classification cross-check