Arseniosiderite
Hydrated calcium–ferric iron arsenate, ideal Ca₂Fe³⁺₃O₂(AsO₄)₃·3H₂O, mitridatite group.
Language and route: Etymology, original referent, and modern taxonomy separately recorded. Ours-Pierre-Armand Petit-Dufrénoy introduced arsénio-sidérite in 1842, combining the arsenic root with Greek sideros, iron. Both elements form the compound's name; the form does not allude to any Cornish mine.
Literal gloss: arsenic + Greek sideros “iron”
Original-language roots
- Arseniosiderite — Original naming pathway in five-question narrative: arsenic + Greek sideros “iron”
The name and its history
Ours-Pierre-Armand Petit-Dufrénoy introduced arsénio-sidérite in 1842, combining the arsenic root with Greek sideros, iron · A.W.G.Kingsbury and J.Hartley.(1957) Mineral.Mag. 31,499.
- What does the word literally mean?
- arsenic + Greek sideros “iron”. Ours-Pierre-Armand Petit-Dufrénoy introduced arsénio-sidérite in 1842, combining the arsenic root with Greek sideros, iron. Both elements form the compound's name; the form does not allude to any Cornish mine.
- What did the original author mean?
- The original reference material was an unusual iron arsenate associated with manganese-ore workings at Romanèche in France. The nineteenth-century description preceded modern understanding of its calcium, oxygen and hydration sites.
- Why was the name needed?
- Yellow-to-brown ferric arsenates are easily confused with scorodite, yukonite and poorly crystalline arsenic-bearing iron oxides. Their cation ratios and crystallographic arrangements were unresolved in early mineral descriptions.
- What evidence supported the original concept?
- Golley and Williams (1995, PDF p. 13) cite A. W. G. Kingsbury and J. Hartley (1957), Mineralogical Magazine 31, 499, for Penberthy Croft Mine, St Hilary. It is a modern analytical Cornish record, not the French naming publication.
- How has geology changed the concept?
- Its modern ideal formula and mitridatite-group position differ substantially from the 1995 manual’s older Ca₃Fe₄(AsO₄)₄(OH)₆·3H₂O formulation; both formulas are recorded in distinct fields to avoid retroactive alteration of the original source.
Further historical context
Ours-Pierre-Armand Petit-Dufrénoy introduced arsénio-sidérite in 1842, combining the arsenic root with Greek sideros, iron. Both elements form the compound's name; the form does not allude to any Cornish mine.
The original reference material was an unusual iron arsenate associated with manganese-ore workings at Romanèche in France. The nineteenth-century description preceded modern understanding of its calcium, oxygen and hydration sites.
Yellow-to-brown ferric arsenates are easily confused with scorodite, yukonite and poorly crystalline arsenic-bearing iron oxides. Their cation ratios and crystallographic arrangements were unresolved in early mineral descriptions.
Golley and Williams (1995, PDF p. 13) cite A. W. G. Kingsbury and J. Hartley (1957), Mineralogical Magazine 31, 499, for Penberthy Croft Mine, St Hilary. It is a modern analytical Cornish record, not the French naming publication.
Its modern ideal formula and mitridatite-group position differ substantially from the 1995 manual’s older Ca₃Fe₄(AsO₄)₄(OH)₆·3H₂O formulation; both formulas are recorded in distinct fields to avoid retroactive alteration of the original source.
Editorial qualification
Valid species, with revised formula; Cornwall occurrence based on the 1957 published reference.; original mineral referent: Romanèche, France
Related names
Sources
- Golley and Williams (1995), Cornish Mineral Reference Manual, PDF p. 13
- Specialist mineral entry: Arseniosiderite — Contemporary nomenclature and mineralogical history